We now have a working spam trap!

Releases and other announcements.
Please don't post support questions here
Forum rules
Section reserved for the team. You can reply to announcements here but not post new topics. Do not add support questions to threads here, use the appropriate support forum instead.
Post Reply
Husse

We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

We have added a couple of steps during registration that will stop all spam bots - human spammers can not be stopped but they are not many.
There are still some users registered that probably are spam bots so we still may get some spam
It is a bit more to do when you register, but you only do that once :)
altair4
Level 20
Level 20
Posts: 11426
Joined: Tue Feb 03, 2009 10:27 am

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by altair4 »

I appreciate your efforts. It was beginning to look like I had logged into a pharmacy website :lol:
Please add a [SOLVED] at the end of your original subject header if your question has been answered and solved.
markcynt

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by markcynt »

Very good. Thank you! A few days ago the spam was ridiculous. :x
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

A few days ago the spam was ridiculous
And the workload to stop it from being even worse was also ridiculous :(
emorrp1

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by emorrp1 »

woooo, good work husse!
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

Actually it was Clem that made it with a little help from me :)
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

I just* banned a user for spamming who entered the forum in March 2009 and posted a couple of normal posts first....
*just = June 1
tinca
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 674
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:23 am
Location: England U.K.

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by tinca »

Husse and Clem,

thank you for your commitment.

Best regards Keith
exploder
Level 15
Level 15
Posts: 5623
Joined: Tue Feb 13, 2007 10:50 am
Location: HartfordCity, Indiana USA

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by exploder »

Thanks guys! The forum looks a lot better today. :D
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

And today (June 2) there was another spam post from someone (rather something) that registered before the change
There will be more spam for some time so please keep an eye open and report (exclamation mark) all spam
User avatar
eiver
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 568
Joined: Fri Jan 23, 2009 5:51 am

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by eiver »

I am not sure if phpBB supports this by default or if there is a plugin that could be installed, but a good idea to get rid of spam would be to allow users to do that. There are many of us so you could use us. And there are few admins, who probably have more important stuff to do than fighting spam bots.

Many sites have a "this is spam" button. If this button is used by enough people, say 5, then it is automatically hidden or deleted. I don't know if the current exclamation mark has this functionality. If it does and people still do not use it, then maybe it would be good to replace the icon with a more descriptive one, so that it includes text like "Mark this as spam" or similar.
User avatar
professorsnapper
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 87
Joined: Mon Jan 14, 2008 8:21 pm
Location: Northern New South Wales

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by professorsnapper »

eiver wrote: I don't know if the current exclamation mark has this functionality. If it does and people still do not use it, then maybe it would be good to replace the icon with a more descriptive one, so that it includes text like "Mark this as spam" or similar.
Agreed. I had no idea this was a spam icon until you mentioned it - how many others would be similarly ignorant?

Also, +1 for forum users to flag spam without relying on forum admin to do all this themselves.
Image
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

Seems you can't change the exclamation mark :(
User avatar
Carl
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 701
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 5:20 pm
Location: Isle of Wight, UK

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Carl »

eiver wrote:I am not sure if phpBB supports this by default or if there is a plugin that could be installed, but a good idea to get rid of spam would be to allow users to do that. There are many of us so you could use us. And there are few admins, who probably have more important stuff to do than fighting spam bots.

Many sites have a "this is spam" button. If this button is used by enough people, say 5, then it is automatically hidden or deleted. I don't know if the current exclamation mark has this functionality
A system like that is just waiting for abuse from script kiddies or angry forum users who register multiple accounts :?
User avatar
professorsnapper
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 87
Joined: Mon Jan 14, 2008 8:21 pm
Location: Northern New South Wales

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by professorsnapper »

Carl wrote: A system like that is just waiting for abuse from script kiddies or angry forum users who register multiple accounts :?
I wonder how other forums (& even sites like youtube) manage this process?
Image
User avatar
Zwopper
Level 10
Level 10
Posts: 3054
Joined: Fri Nov 30, 2007 12:20 pm
Location: Deep in the Swedish woods
Contact:

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Zwopper »

professorsnapper wrote:
eiver wrote: I don't know if the current exclamation mark has this functionality. If it does and people still do not use it, then maybe it would be good to replace the icon with a more descriptive one, so that it includes text like "Mark this as spam" or similar.
Agreed. I had no idea this was a spam icon until you mentioned it - how many others would be similarly ignorant?

Also, +1 for forum users to flag spam without relying on forum admin to do all this themselves.
On the other hand if you hover above the exclamation mark it does say "Report this post" :roll: :wink:
Image
My artwork at deviantART | My Band - Electric Alchemea
CREA DIEM!

Lenovo U330P | i5 | 16GB | 128GB - SSD | Elemantary OS 0.4
User avatar
eiver
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 568
Joined: Fri Jan 23, 2009 5:51 am

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by eiver »

Yeah, but I always thought, that "report this post" is used to report flames. I just clicked the button and there actually is a spam option in the list. But correct me if I am wrong - if I report a post, then an admin still has to review it before it is deleted. This results in a fight between one human admin and a machine spammer (or large number of bad users). I know it all to well. I am the head admin of a much smaller forum (about 100 times smaller than this one). I never had problem with ads and bots, but just resolving user problems like "the occupation of ones mother" took me huge amount of time. I can only imagine how much does it take to handle a huge forum like this one.

Youtube actually deals with that problem the way I described it - you can cast positive or negative votes and based on that the system will automatically hide entries with too much negative votes.

Wikipedia also assumes that most people in the world are good and nice compared to a relatively small number of spammers and jerks. That is why you almost do not see any ads in Wikipedia (or destroyed articles). There is no point. Someone will quickly repair it. Only very controversial topics must be locked.

Btw. current system also is prone to abuse. Suppose some trickster posts tons of ads and also writes a script to report all posts in the forum including his own ads. Generally I think the best way is to trust users, like wikipedia does.
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

Thanks for all the input
We have effectively stopped spambots now so the few reports I get can easily be handled
And it was actually not until late May that spam got so out of hand that it became a major problem to handle
Husse

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by Husse »

The result of the spam trap is fabulous
There is a list in the admin control panel where I can see users that have registered but not yet clicked the activation link in the activation mail that is sent out when you register
Before the spam trap there were at least 30 a day often many more
From the start of the trap on June 1 until today 9 days later there is a total of about a dozen such inactive users
It's odd to see the enormous number of spam bots that registered before (of course there can be the the odd human in between)
I've deleted the lot so we don't get spam from one of these bots
emorrp1

Re: We now have a working spam trap!

Post by emorrp1 »

wow, that's quite effective. It only really got bad at the end of may, but the spam now seems manageable by mere humans, as well as yourself!
Post Reply

Return to “Releases & Announcements”