No HDMI sound -ATI Radeon 4570 [RESOLVED]

[TheKernel]

I am a real newbie who has downloaded LM Nadia to my Acer Aspire 5536G notebook. Most initial problems I have managed to resolve but I have not been able to get any HDMI sound when I connect the laptop to my TV via an HDMI cable (under Windows it was AOK) .

I note from the Nadia release docs that my HDMI hardware (ATI Radeo HD4570) is no longer supported by ATI and an option exists to use the open source driver that comes with Mint. I have presumed this was the case and after trawling the forum and the web I ran two recommended commands in terminal that gave me the following screenshot:


... which seems to tell me that the correct 'snd_hda_intel' driver is loaded for HDMI output. But if that is the case why no sound? ... I did specifically select the HDMI Audio on the output tab under 'sound preferences'.

I have searched across the forums for info/solution but as a 'Linux neophyte', I am now quite confused as to what to do. Any assistance would be appreciated. Thankyou.

Update as at 21/02/13 ... I have searched further across Ubuntu/Linux forums and tried several suggestions for similar reported problems, including "unmuting everything via alsa mixer". There was another suggestion, which I attempted, to reconfigure using "alsaconf" but that program seems to be missing/obsolete now - so if there are any suggestions to help this struggling newbie they would be appreciated. Thanks.

Further update as at 10/03/13 - thanks 'anandrkris' for your support; please see my separate response below as I am embarrassed to say I need further assistancehttp.

Final Update as at 12/03/13 - thank you very much 'anandrkris' and 'cymbaline' ... I followed your advice and now have HDMI sound and have learnt a fair bit along the way also. Thanks again

[Chraz Ritt]

I read on the AMD website that the proprietary drivers for many of their sound and video hardware will not be updated to run under the newer kernel used by mint 14, but they are still supporting the drivers that run under the kernel that is used in mint 13, so if all other options fail you could consider going to it. With that said, please try the info below, it works for me.

Have you tried looking for the sound device control interface? On 13 it can be easily found by clicking menu, then pointing to system tools, followed by clicking system settings, where I can then find an icon for sound, this is likely the same for 14. Once there I find the following interface:



Notice the on/off toggle, make sure it's on, and that the HDMI device is highlighted. Connector needs to be set to "HDMI/DisplayPort".

In the Hardware tab your version of HDMI Audio should be highlighted.

Also the "Profile" at the bottom of the window should be set to something saying HDMI, and not to off.

I find the other 3 tabs unimportant to running sound out through my TV speakers.

I'm not saying that this will cure your problem, but it is a place to look.

[TheKernel]

Thank you Chraz Ritt but it seems the 'sound preferences' window in LM 14 has beeen slightly reconfigured. The output tab now features a 'mute' checkbox for the highlighted device and not an 'on/off' switch and I have just had a look to ensure that the HDMI device is not set to mute. There is also a'profile' settings box for the devices on the hardware tab and everything there looks OK too.

Hopefully something will pop up but thanks again for your response.

[anandrkris]

Did you try the aplay command?

Code: Select all

aplay -l

**** List of PLAYBACK Hardware Devices ****

Code: Select all

aplay -D device_id

Check if this link helps.

Intended Digression - http://community.linuxmint.com/idea/view/3844 - Plese note that I have posted an idea on having a Troubleshotting wizard in Mint for audio related issues. Request you have a look at it and provide your views and if it makes sense - cast your vote on it. Thanks

Am rallying the user forums who have sound issues to get consensus on the idea. Let us join our hands together in building a user-friendly Linux Mint.

[TheKernel]

Thanks 'anandrkris' for your post but I am having problems still; wow ... using the terminal can be a really steep learning curve for newbies. I tried your first aplay command and got -


I was not sure just what the 'device_id' is but I tried the 'aplay -D' command several times .. but just received error messages


I also listed all devices using 'aplay -L' and those mentioning HDMI were -


So I checked on the web for 'device id' for aplay ... but that did not help me ... a bit embarassing really. Can you or somebody else please assist further. Thanks again.

[anandrkris]

Sincere apologies, I should have given complete instructions but am not an expert and only remembered vaguely using the command few times.
I think before going the command way, try installing pavucontrol and set the preferences, it might just easily work.
If pavucontrol does not work - try this
I had to search again and the syntax and it is not very intuitive. Check the quote below from ALSA site.
http://alsa.opensrc.org/Aplay

Device name
It would be nice, to have device name explained (i.e. hw:0,0)
It's ALSA-geek-speak for the initial hardware device that will convert digitzed sample to a smooth analog voltage or vice-versa. See below.
It would be even nicer if the --help and man output of aplay would define what NAME of "--device=NAME" should be set to. Then people would not have to search the Internet to find out.

From the screenshots, the below command should work.

Code: Select all

aplay -D hw:0,1 /usr/share/sounds/alsa/Front_Center.wav

First digit 0 refers to the card ID and second digit refers to the device ID.
I think and easier option is to go to terminal and select the default sound card. (F6)

Code: Select all

alsamixer

Below links are of custom search engines that help in searching linux related topics. I find them to be very useful to solve linux related issues and have them bookmarked..
http://home.windstream.net/joelwest/ - You can filter for 'Mint' to show only results from Mint forums.
http://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=01760 ... _owgx6xyi0

[cymbaline]

I had this issue when I first installed Linux Mint 14 the other day. I googled and found this answer somewhere online and it worked for me. Hope it helps you.

you will need to be root for the following.

you have to edit your grub config. open /etc/default/grub with your preferred text editor and look for GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT and add radeon.audio=1 to the end of it.

GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT="quiet splash"

becomes

GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT="quiet splash radeon.audio=1"

now save the file and run update-grub