A riddle

Chat about just about anything else
Neil Edmond
Level 6
Level 6
Posts: 1115
Joined: Thu Dec 26, 2013 10:19 am
Location: N.E. AR USA

Re: A riddle

Post by Neil Edmond »

It doesn't make any difference whether the initial choice was a goat door or the car door. The host will reveal a goat door after your initial choice, either way. Now all that's left is a 50/50 chance with either decision.

User avatar
slipstick
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 965
Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2012 9:56 pm
Location: Somewhere on the /LL0 scale

Re: A riddle

Post by slipstick »

Neil Edmond wrote:It doesn't make any difference whether the initial choice was a goat door or the car door. The host will reveal a goat door after your initial choice, either way. Now all that's left is a 50/50 chance with either decision.
If your initial choice was a goat, and the host has to reveal the other goat, then changing your choice is a sure winner. If your initial choice was the car, and the host reveals a goat, then changing is a sure loser. When faced with the decision to change or not, you don't know where is the car and where the goat, but you do know that the odds are 2 out of 3 that your initial choice was a goat and so you can win by changing 2 out of 3 times.

It's like a game of dice - just because the sum on two dice can come up anywhere between 2 and 12, if you bet as though the probability of a 2 is the same as that of rolling a 7, pretty soon you will lose.
In theory, theory and practice are the same. In practice, they ain't.

all41
Level 15
Level 15
Posts: 5938
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 9:12 am
Location: Computer, Car, Cage

Re: A riddle

Post by all41 »

slipstick wrote:
Neil Edmond wrote:It doesn't make any difference whether the initial choice was a goat door or the car door. The host will reveal a goat door after your initial choice, either way. Now all that's left is a 50/50 chance with either decision.
If your initial choice was a goat, and the host has to reveal the other goat, then changing your choice is a sure winner. If your initial choice was the car, and the host reveals a goat, then changing is a sure loser. When faced with the decision to change or not, you don't know where is the car and where the goat, but you do know that the odds are 2 out of 3 that your initial choice was a goat and so you can win by changing 2 out of 3 times.

It's like a game of dice - just because the sum on two dice can come up anywhere between 2 and 12, if you bet as though the probability of a 2 is the same as that of rolling a 7, pretty soon you will lose.
Einstein's riddle
The situation

There are 5 houses in five different colors.
In each house lives a person with a different nationality.
These five owners drink a certain type of beverage, smoke a certain brand of cigar and keep a certain pet.
No owners have the same pet, smoke the same brand of cigar or drink the same beverage.

The question is: Who owns the fish?

for clues and solution see here:
https://udel.edu/~os/riddle.html

Penn
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 753
Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:12 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Penn »

What some of you are missing is, in the second choice there is no 3. 1/3 or 2/3 isn't relevant AT ALL.

Once one door with a goat is gone you have a NEW choice with new odds and the the first choice is COMPLETELY irrelevant. What are the possible outcomes of your current choice. One choice is "correct"* and the other is "wrong"* and there is only 2 choices, not 3. If you must bring the first choice into the equation then there is a 50% chance you chose the car the first time and a 50% chance you chose the OTHER goat.
chrisuk wrote:This is probably the original riddle/paradox (from the 1800s)... maybe makes it clearer.
Actually that one is completely different and more interesting because all 3 doors (actually chests in that situation) are still in play for the second choice. I have my view of it but I can see how a person could make a different argument.

My view is there is the first decision, keep it or move on. Keeping it is 50% chance it is both gold, 50% chance it is mixed and 0% chance of just silver. If you choose to keep it then there isn't a second decision with different odds. If you go with changing you have new odds. One of the 2 options has a definite 2 silver and the other either has 2 gold or mixed. So the second choice the odds are 50% silver and the other 50% is split between possibly just gold or mixed so 25% gold and 25% chance it is mixed.

* Correct and wrong are subjective. A person living in a third would place with no access to gas is going to get more use out of a goat.

User avatar
Fred Barclay
Level 12
Level 12
Posts: 4217
Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2014 11:12 am
Location: Swimming

Re: A riddle

Post by Fred Barclay »

all41 wrote: The question is: Who owns the fish?

for clues and solution see here:
https://udel.edu/~os/riddle.html
Just solved this... whew, not easy! :)
I'll PM you my answer as to not mess up the fun for the others.
Image
"Once you can accept the universe as matter expanding into nothing that is something, wearing stripes with plaid comes easy."
- Albert Einstein

all41
Level 15
Level 15
Posts: 5938
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 9:12 am
Location: Computer, Car, Cage

Re: A riddle

Post by all41 »

Fred Barclay wrote:
all41 wrote: The question is: Who owns the fish?

for clues and solution see here:
https://udel.edu/~os/riddle.html
Just solved this... whew, not easy! :)
I'll PM you my answer as to not mess up the fun for the others.
No Fred--it is not Professor Plum

User avatar
sphyrth
Level 4
Level 4
Posts: 332
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 7:14 am

Re: A riddle

Post by sphyrth »

Um... the German?
I have a favorite game. It's on my Youtube Channel.

User avatar
Schultz
Level 7
Level 7
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 8:57 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Schultz »

Penn wrote:
What some of you are missing is, in the second choice there is no 3. 1/3 or 2/3 isn't relevant AT ALL.
But when you made that first choice, your odds of picking a goat was 2 out of 3, so it doesn't matter that a door is opened to reveal a goat, because whether you picked a car or a goat, there is always (at least) one goat left out. So the point is this: that you made your choice before a door was opened. And your odds were 2 out of 3 (higher than 50%) of picking a goat. Revealing a goat behind one of the unchosen doors doesn't change the odds you had when you made your pick . So by switching doors you are theoretically increasing your odds of picking the car. Take a look at Fred Barclay's diagram, noting the purple boxes on the bottom row. 2 out 3 are winners.

User avatar
mintage
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 59
Joined: Fri Dec 30, 2016 3:26 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by mintage »

Neil Edmund gets my vote.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Thanks to the mint support throng goodness
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

User avatar
Schultz
Level 7
Level 7
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 8:57 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Schultz »

I don't know how you can look at the purple boxes in the bottom row of Fred Barclay's diagram and still come to that conclusion.

[ I initially agreed with you guys, until I looked at that diagram. ]

User avatar
mintage
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 59
Joined: Fri Dec 30, 2016 3:26 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by mintage »

Whatever you pick - somebody is going to show you a goat. The first choice is already made, it is either a car or not. the fact that someone shows you a goat has no bearing on the fact that you either select a car or a goat. Changing your mind does not improve your odds, the second goat is just there so it can be taken away. Taking it away is irrelevant - you either picked a car or a goat. The second goat doesn't factor in. It's like a three sided coin and they say "now that the coin is at rest and you do not know which is up, we are going to take away the duplicate side, would you like to change your mind as to which of the two states the coin rests?". The third side is 100% irrelevant. What about the fish?
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Thanks to the mint support throng goodness
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

User avatar
Schultz
Level 7
Level 7
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 8:57 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Schultz »

A door was chosen before any other door was opened. The odds were 1 out 3 that the car was chosen. Opening one of the goat doors doesn't magically change the odds that were there before that door was opened. The odds are still only 1 out 3 that the car was chosen (i.e., if you don't change doors). The green boxes in the bottom row of the diagram proves that.

User avatar
mintage
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 59
Joined: Fri Dec 30, 2016 3:26 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by mintage »

You are correct. It doesn't magically change the odds.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Thanks to the mint support throng goodness
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Neil Edmond
Level 6
Level 6
Posts: 1115
Joined: Thu Dec 26, 2013 10:19 am
Location: N.E. AR USA

Re: A riddle

Post by Neil Edmond »

mintage: Yep.

Shultz: Fred's chart is only applicable if the decision to stick or change is made while 3 doors are still in play. Once the first is revealed the chart is no good anymore.

User avatar
Schultz
Level 7
Level 7
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 8:57 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Schultz »

Neil Edmond wrote:
Fred's chart is only applicable if the decision to stick or change is made while 3 doors are still in play. Once the first is revealed the chart is no good anymore.
That is a good point, but I'm not ready (yet) to go back to my original thoughts on this.

User avatar
sphyrth
Level 4
Level 4
Posts: 332
Joined: Mon Jan 04, 2016 7:14 am

Re: A riddle

Post by sphyrth »

The question is the difference between SWICTHING and STAYING.
You'll SWITCHING into the car 2/3 times.
You'll be STAYING with a goat 2/3 times.

People easily miss the how opening of the other goat helps in increasing the odds by a lot.
I have a favorite game. It's on my Youtube Channel.

User avatar
Portreve
Level 9
Level 9
Posts: 2571
Joined: Mon Apr 18, 2011 12:03 am
Location: Florida
Contact:

Re: A riddle

Post by Portreve »

Um...

Image
There is no spoon...
Please be polite and remember to mark your fixed problem [SOLVED].

Presently running Linux Mint Cinnamon 19.3.

“The avalanche has already started. It is too late for the pebbles to vote.” — Ambassador Kosh

Still looking for a new job.

Penn
Level 5
Level 5
Posts: 753
Joined: Tue Jun 10, 2014 1:12 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Penn »

Schultz wrote:I don't know how you can look at the purple boxes in the bottom row of Fred Barclay's diagram and still come to that conclusion.

[ I initially agreed with you guys, until I looked at that diagram. ]
Fine, you want pictures.

It starts with one alteration, I labeled the doors 1, 2 and 3.

Image

So if you choose door 1, you will be shown door 2 and that option is removed. You can't change your mind AWAY from door 3 since you didn't choose that. So your CURRENT possibilities are

Image

Not a thing erased affects your CURRENT choice and the resulting odds. That stuff is GONE.

This same logic is applicable if your first choice is 2 or 3.

User avatar
mintage
Level 2
Level 2
Posts: 59
Joined: Fri Dec 30, 2016 3:26 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by mintage »

Good Luck Penn, you're a real soldier. :)
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Thanks to the mint support throng goodness
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

User avatar
Schultz
Level 7
Level 7
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thu Feb 25, 2016 8:57 pm

Re: A riddle

Post by Schultz »

The simple solutions above show that a player with a strategy of switching wins the car with overall probability 2/3, i.e., without taking account of which door was opened by the host.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem
"Marilyn vos Savant is an American who is known for having the highest recorded IQ according to the Guinness Book of Records, a competitive category the publication has since retired." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant

She says by switching your odds are now 2 out 3 of winning the car. Is your IQ higher than hers?

Post Reply

Return to “Open chat”